1. Home
2. Categories
3. Outdoor Furniture
4. The Midwesterner’s Guide To Outdoor Furniture Materials: Longevity, Care, And Best Choices

There is a specific heartbreak known only to homeowners in four-season climates. It happens when you pull the cover off your patio set in April, only to find that the “weather-resistant” table you bought two years ago has cracked, peeled, or rusted into oblivion. The furniture that looked pristine in the showroom simply couldn’t handle the silent, brutal work of a Midwestern winter.

The truth is, buying outdoor furniture isn’t just about selecting a style that matches your deck; it’s about choosing engineering that can survive an environment that shifts from 95°F and humid to -10°F and icy. While proper outdoor furniture care is essential for extending the life of any piece, the battle for longevity is largely won or lost the moment you decide on the material.

The Science of Survival: Why Furniture Fails

Before we compare specific materials, it helps to understand exactly what your furniture is up against. In regions like St. Louis, we don’t just deal with “weather.” We deal with three specific forces that degrade materials differently:

1. The Freeze-Thaw Cycle: This is the silent killer. When moisture seeps into porous materials (like low-grade wicker or unsealed softwoods), it freezes in winter. As water freezes, it expands, causing microscopic cracks that eventually shatter the material.
2. UV Degradation: The summer sun doesn’t just make things hot; ultraviolet rays break down the chemical bonds in plastics and paints, leading to fading and brittleness.
3. Humidity Shifts: High humidity causes wood to swell, while dry spells cause it to shrink. Constant fluctuation can warp furniture that isn’t built with the right joinery or material density.

The Contenders: A Material Comparison

When you strip away the marketing terms, most high-quality outdoor furniture falls into one of four categories: Metals (Aluminum/Iron), Woods (Teak), Wovens (Resin Wicker), and Synthetics (HDPE). Here is how they stack up when faced with our climate.

1. Aluminum: The Low-Maintenance Champion

If you are looking for the best material for outdoor furniture in terms of “set it and forget it” convenience, aluminum is the reigning king.

• Why it works: Unlike iron or steel, aluminum creates its own protective oxide layer, meaning it technically cannot rust. High-quality aluminum furniture is usually powder-coated, which adds a baked-on layer of color and protection.
• The Midwest Advantage: It is impervious to moisture. Snow, rain, and humidity have zero effect on the structural integrity of the metal.
• The Trade-off: Standard tubular aluminum is lightweight. In areas with high winds, this can be a disadvantage unless you opt for “cast aluminum,” which is solid, heavier, and features intricate designs.

Midwest Suitability Score: ★★★★★

Maintenance Level: Very Low. Occasional cleaning with soap and water.

2. Teak: The Gold Standard of Woods

For centuries, shipbuilders used teak for decks because it is one of the only woods that naturally repels water. Today, teak outdoor furniture remains the pinnacle of durability for wood lovers.

• Why it works: Teak is dense and saturated with natural rubber and oils. These oils act as a built-in preservative, preventing rot, fungi, and warping, even when left exposed to the elements.
• The Midwest Advantage: Teak does not feel the cold like metal does. It remains comfortable to the touch in cooler weather. Because it is heavy and dense, it won’t blow over in a spring storm.
• The “Aha” Moment: Many buyers assume wood requires constant staining. With high-quality teak, you have a choice. You can oil it annually to keep the honey-brown look, or you can do absolutely nothing. If left alone, teak will weather to a distinguished silvery-gray patina. This change is cosmetic, not structural.
• Learn More: Explore our collection of teak outdoor furniture to see how these pieces blend durability with timeless style.

Midwest Suitability Score: ★★★★☆

Maintenance Level: Low to Medium (depending on your color preference).

3. All-Weather Wicker: The Modern Evolution

“Wicker” is actually a technique of weaving, not a material. Historically, wicker was made from rattan or cane, which rots rapidly outdoors. Modern “All-Weather Wicker” is made from High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE) resin woven over an aluminum frame.

• Why it works: High-quality resin wicker is dyed all the way through (not just painted on the surface) and contains UV inhibitors to prevent cracking and peeling.
• The Midwest Advantage: It offers the texture and warmth of a natural material but is completely impervious to the freeze-thaw cycle—provided you buy high-quality resin. Cheap PVC vinyl wickers will become brittle and crack in freezing temperatures.
• The Trade-off: You must ensure the frame underneath the weave is aluminum. If the weave is over steel, the frame can rust and stain your patio.

Midwest Suitability Score: ★★★★☆

Maintenance Level: Low. Hose it off; check the weave for loose ends occasionally.

4. Wrought Iron: The Heavyweight Classic

Wrought iron is the strongest material available. It is incredibly heavy, making it the best material for outdoor furniture in extremely windy locations.

• Why it works: It is solid and virtually indestructible structurally.
• The Midwest Advantage: It will never blow away.
• The Trade-off: Iron rusts. To survive a St. Louis winter, it needs a pristine powder coat. If that coat chips, rust will form. However, this is manageable with occasional touch-ups using outdoor furniture touch up paint.

Midwest Suitability Score: ★★★☆☆

Maintenance Level: Medium. Requires inspection for chips and rust spots.

Teak vs. Aluminum Patio Furniture: How to Choose?

The most common debate we see in our showroom is the battle between the warmth of wood and the practicality of metal. Here is a quick way to decide.

| Feature | Teak | Cast Aluminum |

| :— | :— | :— |

| Aesthetic | Warm, organic, traditional, ages gracefully. | Sleek, classic or modern, holds color permanently. |

| Temperature | Neutral; doesn’t get scorching hot or freezing cold. | Can get hot in direct sun; cold in winter. |

| Maintenance | Needs oiling to stay brown; otherwise maintenance-free. | Wash and go. |

| Longevity | 25+ years (heirloom quality). | 15-20+ years. |

| Best For… | Covered patios, garden settings, wind prone areas. | Poolside, uncovered decks, busy families. |

If you love the idea of metal but want to browse options locally, you can view our discount patio furniture St Louis selection for high-quality aluminum pieces that fit various budgets.

Common Misconceptions About Outdoor Materials

Myth 1: “Waterproof” covers mean I can buy cheaper furniture.

Reality: Covers are excellent, but they are not hermetic seals. Condensation can build up inside a cover, creating a greenhouse effect that accelerates mold on low-quality woods or rust on steel. Covers protect high-quality materials; they cannot save poor-quality ones.

Myth 2: Heavy furniture is always better.

Reality: Weight indicates density, which is good for wind resistance. However, weight does not equal durability. Particleboard is heavy, but it dissolves in water. Tubular aluminum is light, but lasts for decades. Look for density in wood and gauge (thickness) in metal.

Myth 3: “All-Weather” means I can leave the cushions out.

Reality: The frame might be all-weather, but cushions are different. Even the best outdoor fabrics (like solution-dyed acrylics) should be brought in during winter or heavy storms to prevent mildew growing on the dirt trapped in the fabric.

Making the Right Investment

Choosing the right material is about matching the furniture’s capabilities to your lifestyle and your landscape. If you are willing to do a little annual oiling for the sake of unmatched beauty, teak is a choice you will never regret. If you want a dining set that you can hose down before a BBQ and never think about again, aluminum is your answer.

Regardless of what you choose, remember that outdoor furniture in the Midwest is an investment in your home. Buying quality once is always more economical than replacing “disposable” furniture every three years.

For those ready to explore these materials in person, Forshaw of St. Louis offers a curated selection of brands that have been vetted for our specific climate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I leave aluminum furniture out in the snow?

A: Yes. High-quality powder-coated aluminum is non-porous and will not be damaged by snow or freezing temperatures. However, we recommend covering it to keep it clean and protect the finish from falling branches or debris.

Q: Does teak turn gray immediately?

A: No. New teak comes with a golden-honey color. Depending on the amount of sun and rain it receives, it will gradually weather to a silver-gray patina over 6 to 12 months. This does not affect the strength of the wood.

Q: Is there a difference between “rattan” and “wicker”?

A: Yes. Rattan is a material (a vine), while wicker is the style of weave. You should avoid natural rattan for outdoor use in the Midwest as it rots. Look for “resin wicker” or “HDPE wicker” for outdoor longevity.

Q: How do I fix a scratch on my aluminum furniture?

A: If the powder coat gets scratched, it’s purely cosmetic for aluminum (since it doesn’t rust), but you can easily fix it with touch-up paint specifically designed for metal furniture frames.

Previous Next